Publication details

Saarland University Computer Science

Comparing Trailing and Copying for Constraint Programming

Christian Schulte

Proceedings of the Sixteenth International Conference on Logic Programming, pp. 275--289, The MIT Press, November 1999

A central service of a constraint programming system is search. In almost all constraint programming systems search is based on trailing, which is well understood and known to be efficient. This paper compares trailing to copying. Copying offers more expressiveness as required by parallel and concurrent systems. However, little is known how trailing compares to copying as it comes to implementation effort, runtime efficiency, and memory requirements. This paper discusses these issues.
Execution speed of a copying-based system is shown to be competitive with state-of-the-art trailing-based systems. For the first time, a detailed analysis and comparison with respect to memory usage is made. It is shown how recomputation decreases memory requirements which can be prohibitive for large problems with copying alone. The paper introduces an adaptive recomputation strategy that is shown to speedup search while keeping memory consumption low. It is demonstrated that copying with recomputation outperforms trailing on large problems with respect to both space and time.

Download PDF        Show BibTeX               


Login to edit


Webmaster, Wed Sep 16 10:47:00 2009