(**************************************************************)
(* Copyright Dominique Larchey-Wendling * *)
(* *)
(* * Affiliation LORIA -- CNRS *)
(**************************************************************)
(* This file is distributed under the terms of the *)
(* CeCILL v2 FREE SOFTWARE LICENSE AGREEMENT *)
(**************************************************************)
Require Import List Arith Lia.
From Undecidability.Shared.Libs.DLW
Require Import utils_tac utils_nat utils_list crt pos vec.
From Undecidability.MuRec
Require Import recalg ra_utils ra_enum recomp ra_recomp beta ra_godel_beta.
From Undecidability.DiophantineConstraints
Require Import H10C Util.h10c_utils.
Set Implicit Arguments.
Set Default Proof Using "Type".
Local Notation "'⟦' f '⟧'" := (@ra_rel _ f) (at level 0).
Definition h10uc_eq a' b' (c : nat*nat*nat) :=
match c with (x,y,z) =>
let vx := godel_beta a' b' x in
let vy := godel_beta a' b' y in
let vz := godel_beta a' b' z
in 1+vx+vy*vy = vz
end.
Definition h10uc_test a' b' x y z :=
let vx := godel_beta a' b' x in
let vy := godel_beta a' b' y in
let vz := godel_beta a' b' z
in if eq_nat_dec (1+vx+vy*vy) vz then 0 else 1.
Definition idx_h10uc a b p : h10uc :=
(godel_beta a b (3*p), godel_beta a b (1+3*p), godel_beta a b (2+3*p)).
Definition nat_h10luc k :=
let n := decomp_r k in
let a := decomp_l (decomp_l k) in
let b := decomp_r (decomp_l k)
in map (fun p => idx_h10uc a b (pos2nat p)) (pos_list n).
(* nat_h10luc is surjective
needed to map an H10UC instance to a instance of the universal solver
*)
Fact nat_h10luc_surj lc : { k | lc = nat_h10luc k }.
Proof.
destruct (list_vec_full lc) as (v & <-).
set (n := length lc).
set (f p := match le_lt_dec n p with
| left _ => (0,0,0)
| right Hp => vec_pos v (nat2pos Hp)
end).
destruct godel_beta_fun_inv_triples with (n := n) (f := f)
as (a & b & Hab).
exists (recomp (recomp a b) n).
unfold nat_h10luc.
repeat (rewrite decomp_l_recomp).
repeat rewrite decomp_r_recomp.
rewrite map_pos_list_vec; f_equal.
apply vec_pos_ext; intros p; rewrite vec_pos_set.
unfold idx_h10uc; rewrite <- Hab; auto.
2: apply pos2nat_prop.
unfold f, n.
destruct (le_lt_dec (length lc) (pos2nat p)) as [ H | H ].
+ generalize (pos2nat_prop p); lia.
+ rewrite nat2pos_pos2nat; auto.
Qed.
Section ra_h10uc.
Let s : recalg 1.
Proof.
ra root ra_mult; ra arg pos0.
Defined.
Let s_val x : ⟦s⟧ (x##vec_nil) (x*x).
Proof.
unfold s.
exists (x##x##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Definition ra_h10uc : recalg 5.
Proof.
ra root ra_not.
ra root ra_not.
ra root ra_eq.
+ ra root ra_succ.
ra root ra_plus.
* ra root ra_godel_beta.
- ra arg pos3.
- ra arg pos4.
- ra arg pos0.
* ra root s.
ra root ra_godel_beta.
- ra arg pos3.
- ra arg pos4.
- ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos3.
* ra arg pos4.
* ra arg pos2.
Defined.
Opaque ra_not ra_eq ra_plus ra_mult ra_cst_n ra_godel_beta.
Fact ra_h10uc_prim_rec : prim_rec ra_h10uc.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Opaque s.
Variable x y z a' b' : nat.
Let vx := godel_beta a' b' x.
Let vy := godel_beta a' b' y.
Let vz := godel_beta a' b' z.
Fact ra_h10uc_val : ⟦ra_h10uc⟧ (x##y##z##a'##b'##vec_nil) (h10uc_test a' b' x y z).
Proof.
exists (1-ite_rel (1+vx+vy*vy-vz) (vz-(1+vx+vy*vy)) 1##vec_nil); split.
{ generalize (ra_not_val (1-ite_rel (1+vx+vy*vy-vz) (vz-(1+vx+vy*vy)) 1)).
intros H; eq goal H; f_equal.
unfold ite_rel, h10uc_test.
fold vx; fold vy; fold vz.
case_eq (1 + vx + vy * vy - vz); destruct (eq_nat_dec (1+vx+vy*vy) vz); intros; lia. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (ite_rel (1+vx+vy*vy-vz) (vz-(1+vx+vy*vy)) 1##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (1+vx+vy*vy##vz##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_eq_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (vx+vy*vy##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (vx##vy*vy##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (a'##b'##x##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_godel_beta_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (vy##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split.
exists (a'##b'##y##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_godel_beta_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a'##b'##z##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_godel_beta_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
End ra_h10uc.
Local Hint Resolve ra_h10uc_prim_rec ra_h10uc_val : core.
Opaque ra_h10uc.
Section ra_iter_h10uc.
Let t3 : recalg 1.
Proof.
ra root ra_mult.
- ra cst 3.
- ra arg pos0.
Defined.
Let t3_val n : ⟦t3⟧ (n##vec_nil) (3*n).
Proof.
exists (3##n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
apply ra_cst_n_val.
Qed.
Let f : recalg 5.
Proof.
ra root ra_h10uc.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos1.
* ra arg pos2.
* ra root t3.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos1.
* ra arg pos2.
* ra root ra_succ.
ra root t3.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos1.
* ra arg pos2.
* ra root ra_succ.
ra root ra_succ.
ra root t3.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra arg pos3.
+ ra arg pos4.
Defined.
Opaque ra_godel_beta ra_mult ra_cst_n.
Let f_pr : prim_rec f.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Opaque t3 mult.
Let f_val n a b a' b' : ⟦f⟧ (n##a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil)
(h10uc_test a' b' (godel_beta a b (3*n))
(godel_beta a b (1+3*n))
(godel_beta a b (2+3*n))).
Proof.
exists (godel_beta a b (3*n)##godel_beta a b (1+3*n)##godel_beta a b (2+3*n)##a'##b'##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a##b##3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a##b##1+3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a##b##2+3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (1+3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Opaque f.
Definition ra_iter_h10uc : recalg 5.
Proof.
ra root ra_not.
ra root ra_not.
apply (ra_lsum f).
Defined.
Fact ra_iter_h10uc_prim_rec : prim_rec ra_iter_h10uc.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Section ra_iter_spec.
Variable (n a b a' b' : nat).
Fact ra_iter_h10uc_val_0 :
(forall p, p < n -> h10uc_eq a' b' (idx_h10uc a b p))
-> ⟦ra_iter_h10uc⟧ (n##a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil) 0.
Proof.
intros H2; simpl.
exists (1##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (0##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
apply ra_lsum_0.
intros p Hp.
specialize (H2 _ Hp).
unfold h10uc_eq, idx_h10uc in H2.
generalize (f_val p a b a' b').
unfold h10uc_test.
match type of H2 with
| ?a = ?b => destruct (eq_nat_dec a b)
end; auto; lia.
Qed.
Fact ra_iter_h10uc_val_1 :
(exists p, p < n /\ ~ h10uc_eq a' b' (idx_h10uc a b p))
-> ⟦ra_iter_h10uc⟧ (n##a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil) 1.
Proof.
intros H2; simpl.
exists (0##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
destruct ra_lsum_S with (1 := f_pr) (i := n) (v := a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil)
as (k & Hk).
{ destruct H2 as (p & H2 & H3).
exists p, 0; split; auto.
unfold h10uc_eq, idx_h10uc in H3.
generalize (f_val p a b a' b').
unfold h10uc_test.
match type of H3 with
| ?a <> ?b => destruct (eq_nat_dec a b)
end; auto; lia. }
exists (S k##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
End ra_iter_spec.
End ra_iter_h10uc.
Local Hint Resolve ra_iter_h10uc_prim_rec : core.
Opaque ra_iter_h10uc.
Section ra_univ_ad.
Let f : recalg 2.
Proof.
ra root ra_iter_h10uc.
+ ra root ra_decomp_r.
ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_decomp_r.
ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra root ra_decomp_r.
ra arg pos0.
Defined.
Opaque ra_decomp_l ra_decomp_r.
Let Hf_pr : prim_rec f.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Variables (lc : list h10uc) (k : nat)
(Hlc : lc = nat_h10luc k).
Let Hf_val_0 v :
(forall c, In c lc -> h10uc_sem (godel_beta (decomp_l v) (decomp_r v)) c)
-> ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 0.
Proof.
intros H2.
exists (decomp_r k##decomp_l (decomp_l k)##decomp_r (decomp_l k)##
decomp_l v##decomp_r v##vec_nil); split.
+ apply ra_iter_h10uc_val_0.
intros p Hp.
apply H2; subst.
unfold idx_h10uc.
apply in_map_iff.
exists (nat2pos Hp); split.
* rewrite pos2nat_nat2pos; auto.
* apply pos_list_prop.
+ pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Let Hf_val_1 v :
(exists c, In c lc /\ ~ h10uc_sem (godel_beta (decomp_l v) (decomp_r v)) c)
-> ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 1.
Proof.
intros H2.
exists (decomp_r k##decomp_l (decomp_l k)##decomp_r (decomp_l k)##
decomp_l v##decomp_r v##vec_nil); split.
+ apply ra_iter_h10uc_val_1.
destruct H2 as (c & H1 & H2).
rewrite Hlc in H1.
unfold nat_h10luc in H1.
apply in_map_iff in H1.
destruct H1 as (p & H1 & _).
exists (pos2nat p); split.
* apply pos2nat_prop.
* rewrite H1; auto.
+ pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Let Hf_tot v : ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 0 \/ ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 1.
Proof.
destruct (h10luc_sem_dec lc (godel_beta (decomp_l v) (decomp_r v)))
as [ (c & H) | H ].
+ right; apply Hf_val_1; exists c; auto.
+ left; apply Hf_val_0; auto.
Qed.
Definition ra_univ_ad : recalg 1.
Proof. apply ra_min, f. Defined.
Opaque f.
Theorem ra_univ_ad_spec : ex (⟦ra_univ_ad⟧ (k##vec_nil))
<-> exists φ, forall c, In c lc -> h10uc_sem φ c.
Proof using Hf_tot.
split.
+ intros (v & Hv).
simpl in Hv; red in Hv.
destruct Hv as (H1 & H2).
destruct (h10luc_sem_dec lc (beta v))
as [ (c & H) | H ].
* assert (⟦ f ⟧ (v ## k ## vec_nil) 1) as C.
{ apply Hf_val_1; exists c; auto. }
generalize (ra_rel_fun _ _ _ _ H1 C); discriminate.
* exists (beta v); auto.
+ intros (phi & Hphi).
destruct (godel_beta_fun_inv (h10luc_bound lc) phi)
as (a & b & Hab).
generalize (h10luc_bound_prop _ _ Hab); clear Hab; intros Hab.
apply ra_min_ex; auto.
exists (recomp a b); simpl.
apply Hf_val_0.
intros c Hc; rewrite decomp_l_recomp, decomp_r_recomp; apply Hab; auto.
Qed.
End ra_univ_ad.
(* Copyright Dominique Larchey-Wendling * *)
(* *)
(* * Affiliation LORIA -- CNRS *)
(**************************************************************)
(* This file is distributed under the terms of the *)
(* CeCILL v2 FREE SOFTWARE LICENSE AGREEMENT *)
(**************************************************************)
Require Import List Arith Lia.
From Undecidability.Shared.Libs.DLW
Require Import utils_tac utils_nat utils_list crt pos vec.
From Undecidability.MuRec
Require Import recalg ra_utils ra_enum recomp ra_recomp beta ra_godel_beta.
From Undecidability.DiophantineConstraints
Require Import H10C Util.h10c_utils.
Set Implicit Arguments.
Set Default Proof Using "Type".
Local Notation "'⟦' f '⟧'" := (@ra_rel _ f) (at level 0).
Definition h10uc_eq a' b' (c : nat*nat*nat) :=
match c with (x,y,z) =>
let vx := godel_beta a' b' x in
let vy := godel_beta a' b' y in
let vz := godel_beta a' b' z
in 1+vx+vy*vy = vz
end.
Definition h10uc_test a' b' x y z :=
let vx := godel_beta a' b' x in
let vy := godel_beta a' b' y in
let vz := godel_beta a' b' z
in if eq_nat_dec (1+vx+vy*vy) vz then 0 else 1.
Definition idx_h10uc a b p : h10uc :=
(godel_beta a b (3*p), godel_beta a b (1+3*p), godel_beta a b (2+3*p)).
Definition nat_h10luc k :=
let n := decomp_r k in
let a := decomp_l (decomp_l k) in
let b := decomp_r (decomp_l k)
in map (fun p => idx_h10uc a b (pos2nat p)) (pos_list n).
(* nat_h10luc is surjective
needed to map an H10UC instance to a instance of the universal solver
*)
Fact nat_h10luc_surj lc : { k | lc = nat_h10luc k }.
Proof.
destruct (list_vec_full lc) as (v & <-).
set (n := length lc).
set (f p := match le_lt_dec n p with
| left _ => (0,0,0)
| right Hp => vec_pos v (nat2pos Hp)
end).
destruct godel_beta_fun_inv_triples with (n := n) (f := f)
as (a & b & Hab).
exists (recomp (recomp a b) n).
unfold nat_h10luc.
repeat (rewrite decomp_l_recomp).
repeat rewrite decomp_r_recomp.
rewrite map_pos_list_vec; f_equal.
apply vec_pos_ext; intros p; rewrite vec_pos_set.
unfold idx_h10uc; rewrite <- Hab; auto.
2: apply pos2nat_prop.
unfold f, n.
destruct (le_lt_dec (length lc) (pos2nat p)) as [ H | H ].
+ generalize (pos2nat_prop p); lia.
+ rewrite nat2pos_pos2nat; auto.
Qed.
Section ra_h10uc.
Let s : recalg 1.
Proof.
ra root ra_mult; ra arg pos0.
Defined.
Let s_val x : ⟦s⟧ (x##vec_nil) (x*x).
Proof.
unfold s.
exists (x##x##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Definition ra_h10uc : recalg 5.
Proof.
ra root ra_not.
ra root ra_not.
ra root ra_eq.
+ ra root ra_succ.
ra root ra_plus.
* ra root ra_godel_beta.
- ra arg pos3.
- ra arg pos4.
- ra arg pos0.
* ra root s.
ra root ra_godel_beta.
- ra arg pos3.
- ra arg pos4.
- ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos3.
* ra arg pos4.
* ra arg pos2.
Defined.
Opaque ra_not ra_eq ra_plus ra_mult ra_cst_n ra_godel_beta.
Fact ra_h10uc_prim_rec : prim_rec ra_h10uc.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Opaque s.
Variable x y z a' b' : nat.
Let vx := godel_beta a' b' x.
Let vy := godel_beta a' b' y.
Let vz := godel_beta a' b' z.
Fact ra_h10uc_val : ⟦ra_h10uc⟧ (x##y##z##a'##b'##vec_nil) (h10uc_test a' b' x y z).
Proof.
exists (1-ite_rel (1+vx+vy*vy-vz) (vz-(1+vx+vy*vy)) 1##vec_nil); split.
{ generalize (ra_not_val (1-ite_rel (1+vx+vy*vy-vz) (vz-(1+vx+vy*vy)) 1)).
intros H; eq goal H; f_equal.
unfold ite_rel, h10uc_test.
fold vx; fold vy; fold vz.
case_eq (1 + vx + vy * vy - vz); destruct (eq_nat_dec (1+vx+vy*vy) vz); intros; lia. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (ite_rel (1+vx+vy*vy-vz) (vz-(1+vx+vy*vy)) 1##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (1+vx+vy*vy##vz##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_eq_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (vx+vy*vy##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (vx##vy*vy##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (a'##b'##x##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_godel_beta_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (vy##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split.
exists (a'##b'##y##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_godel_beta_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a'##b'##z##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ apply ra_godel_beta_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
End ra_h10uc.
Local Hint Resolve ra_h10uc_prim_rec ra_h10uc_val : core.
Opaque ra_h10uc.
Section ra_iter_h10uc.
Let t3 : recalg 1.
Proof.
ra root ra_mult.
- ra cst 3.
- ra arg pos0.
Defined.
Let t3_val n : ⟦t3⟧ (n##vec_nil) (3*n).
Proof.
exists (3##n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
apply ra_cst_n_val.
Qed.
Let f : recalg 5.
Proof.
ra root ra_h10uc.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos1.
* ra arg pos2.
* ra root t3.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos1.
* ra arg pos2.
* ra root ra_succ.
ra root t3.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra root ra_godel_beta.
* ra arg pos1.
* ra arg pos2.
* ra root ra_succ.
ra root ra_succ.
ra root t3.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra arg pos3.
+ ra arg pos4.
Defined.
Opaque ra_godel_beta ra_mult ra_cst_n.
Let f_pr : prim_rec f.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Opaque t3 mult.
Let f_val n a b a' b' : ⟦f⟧ (n##a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil)
(h10uc_test a' b' (godel_beta a b (3*n))
(godel_beta a b (1+3*n))
(godel_beta a b (2+3*n))).
Proof.
exists (godel_beta a b (3*n)##godel_beta a b (1+3*n)##godel_beta a b (2+3*n)##a'##b'##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a##b##3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a##b##1+3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
+ exists (a##b##2+3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (1+3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (3*n##vec_nil); split; auto.
{ simpl; auto. }
pos split; simpl.
exists (n##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Opaque f.
Definition ra_iter_h10uc : recalg 5.
Proof.
ra root ra_not.
ra root ra_not.
apply (ra_lsum f).
Defined.
Fact ra_iter_h10uc_prim_rec : prim_rec ra_iter_h10uc.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Section ra_iter_spec.
Variable (n a b a' b' : nat).
Fact ra_iter_h10uc_val_0 :
(forall p, p < n -> h10uc_eq a' b' (idx_h10uc a b p))
-> ⟦ra_iter_h10uc⟧ (n##a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil) 0.
Proof.
intros H2; simpl.
exists (1##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (0##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
apply ra_lsum_0.
intros p Hp.
specialize (H2 _ Hp).
unfold h10uc_eq, idx_h10uc in H2.
generalize (f_val p a b a' b').
unfold h10uc_test.
match type of H2 with
| ?a = ?b => destruct (eq_nat_dec a b)
end; auto; lia.
Qed.
Fact ra_iter_h10uc_val_1 :
(exists p, p < n /\ ~ h10uc_eq a' b' (idx_h10uc a b p))
-> ⟦ra_iter_h10uc⟧ (n##a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil) 1.
Proof.
intros H2; simpl.
exists (0##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
destruct ra_lsum_S with (1 := f_pr) (i := n) (v := a##b##a'##b'##vec_nil)
as (k & Hk).
{ destruct H2 as (p & H2 & H3).
exists p, 0; split; auto.
unfold h10uc_eq, idx_h10uc in H3.
generalize (f_val p a b a' b').
unfold h10uc_test.
match type of H3 with
| ?a <> ?b => destruct (eq_nat_dec a b)
end; auto; lia. }
exists (S k##vec_nil); split.
{ apply ra_not_val. }
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
End ra_iter_spec.
End ra_iter_h10uc.
Local Hint Resolve ra_iter_h10uc_prim_rec : core.
Opaque ra_iter_h10uc.
Section ra_univ_ad.
Let f : recalg 2.
Proof.
ra root ra_iter_h10uc.
+ ra root ra_decomp_r.
ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_decomp_r.
ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra arg pos1.
+ ra root ra_decomp_l.
ra arg pos0.
+ ra root ra_decomp_r.
ra arg pos0.
Defined.
Opaque ra_decomp_l ra_decomp_r.
Let Hf_pr : prim_rec f.
Proof. ra prim rec. Qed.
Variables (lc : list h10uc) (k : nat)
(Hlc : lc = nat_h10luc k).
Let Hf_val_0 v :
(forall c, In c lc -> h10uc_sem (godel_beta (decomp_l v) (decomp_r v)) c)
-> ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 0.
Proof.
intros H2.
exists (decomp_r k##decomp_l (decomp_l k)##decomp_r (decomp_l k)##
decomp_l v##decomp_r v##vec_nil); split.
+ apply ra_iter_h10uc_val_0.
intros p Hp.
apply H2; subst.
unfold idx_h10uc.
apply in_map_iff.
exists (nat2pos Hp); split.
* rewrite pos2nat_nat2pos; auto.
* apply pos_list_prop.
+ pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Let Hf_val_1 v :
(exists c, In c lc /\ ~ h10uc_sem (godel_beta (decomp_l v) (decomp_r v)) c)
-> ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 1.
Proof.
intros H2.
exists (decomp_r k##decomp_l (decomp_l k)##decomp_r (decomp_l k)##
decomp_l v##decomp_r v##vec_nil); split.
+ apply ra_iter_h10uc_val_1.
destruct H2 as (c & H1 & H2).
rewrite Hlc in H1.
unfold nat_h10luc in H1.
apply in_map_iff in H1.
destruct H1 as (p & H1 & _).
exists (pos2nat p); split.
* apply pos2nat_prop.
* rewrite H1; auto.
+ pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (decomp_l k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
exists (k##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
* exists (v##vec_nil); split; auto.
pos split; simpl; auto.
Qed.
Let Hf_tot v : ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 0 \/ ⟦f⟧ (v##k##vec_nil) 1.
Proof.
destruct (h10luc_sem_dec lc (godel_beta (decomp_l v) (decomp_r v)))
as [ (c & H) | H ].
+ right; apply Hf_val_1; exists c; auto.
+ left; apply Hf_val_0; auto.
Qed.
Definition ra_univ_ad : recalg 1.
Proof. apply ra_min, f. Defined.
Opaque f.
Theorem ra_univ_ad_spec : ex (⟦ra_univ_ad⟧ (k##vec_nil))
<-> exists φ, forall c, In c lc -> h10uc_sem φ c.
Proof using Hf_tot.
split.
+ intros (v & Hv).
simpl in Hv; red in Hv.
destruct Hv as (H1 & H2).
destruct (h10luc_sem_dec lc (beta v))
as [ (c & H) | H ].
* assert (⟦ f ⟧ (v ## k ## vec_nil) 1) as C.
{ apply Hf_val_1; exists c; auto. }
generalize (ra_rel_fun _ _ _ _ H1 C); discriminate.
* exists (beta v); auto.
+ intros (phi & Hphi).
destruct (godel_beta_fun_inv (h10luc_bound lc) phi)
as (a & b & Hab).
generalize (h10luc_bound_prop _ _ Hab); clear Hab; intros Hab.
apply ra_min_ex; auto.
exists (recomp a b); simpl.
apply Hf_val_0.
intros c Hc; rewrite decomp_l_recomp, decomp_r_recomp; apply Hab; auto.
Qed.
End ra_univ_ad.